January 5, 1997
Dear Daniel,
This morning was my first time playing guitar in front of an audience. The church was only half full because a lot of people are still getting back from the holidays. I was glad for that, because it went terribly.
So, here’s what happened. Pastor Joe prayed before the offertory, and that was when my sisters and I got set up. I grabbed my guitar from the stand and sat on a tall stool with a red cushion. My sisters stood next to me. Remember how I said I was going to use that new picking technique? What I didn’t expect was how badly my right hand would shake because I was so nervous. I could hardly do it. It took so much concentration. Sometimes I would completely miss the string. Like a whiff! I’m pretty sure I blacked out for part of it. My mind couldn’t stop thinking about how badly things were going. All I did was stare straight down at my strings, which was nice because that way people couldn’t see my face, which felt like a ball of lava. I just kept thinking how I wished the rapture would happen immediately.
Do you know what the rapture is? It’s something we believe at our church, that Jesus is going to come back, maybe entering from the clouds or maybe some other way. I don’t think we know totally for sure, but we’re taught that the timing of it could be any day now. So I’ve always prayed that Jesus would wait to come back at least until I’ve experienced sexual intercourse. That’s something I really want to do, but not until I’m married, which is also something we believe in. That you should wait to have sex until you’re married. Since I’m only 15, that’s a ways off. And especially when everybody at church says Jesus could come back any day, I get a little bummed out because there’s so much I still want to do in life, especially have sex.
But while I was up there with my sisters struggling to play the guitar, all that went away. In fact, it was the opposite. I felt like I’d lived a decent life. Fifteen years is pretty good. I just wanted Jesus to come back immediately or, if not, could he at least make somebody pull the fire alarm or something.
That’s how it felt.
I thought it was going to feel so good, like how I’d imagined it the night before. When my sisters and I practiced at the church with the microphones, it was actually good. I had fun. I fell asleep dreaming about how nice it was going to be to see everyone watch how good I was. I wasn’t just a “hockey quitter.” I had done something constructive with my time, and the potential would be clear to everyone. I imagined a lot of people thinking, Thank goodness he did quit hockey because otherwise we would never have witnessed this.
But when I was up there, I swore to myself I’d never perform again. We finished the song and sat down, and after church I was ready to walk out and wait in the minivan until my parents and sisters came out.
That’s when the strangest thing happened. My friend’s mom said,
“That was awesome! You guys sounded so great.”
And then another person said,
“I didn’t know you played the guitar. That was cool.”
I wanted to ask them if they were sure it was me they were talking about. I wanted to say, “But didn’t you hear all those mistakes?” I wanted to tell them how much better it was when we practiced the night before. But I didn’t say anything. I just said thanks. Still, I was pretty embarrassed.
And so even though I promised myself I’d never perform again, that thought got mixed up with the compliments, which felt pretty nice, even though I had a hard time receiving them.
I don’t know what to do.
We went to Hardee’s for hamburgers and roast beef sandwiches after. I’m usually starving and eat a lot, but I could hardly eat. I kept thinking about how bad it felt up there playing. I didn’t enjoy one second of it. To tell you the truth, I’m surprised we even made it through the song. But nobody mentioned my mistakes.
Later, I even asked my friend’s mom straight out if she really didn’t hear them, because I needed to know. She said maybe it’s harder to notice with guitar. And people aren’t used to hearing guitar in church. It’s almost always piano. So maybe that’s part of the reason. I don’t know.
Did your first performance feel as terrible as mine? What’s weird is I love guitar so much and want to keep playing, but that performance felt as bad as it used to when I was little and my parents made me sing with my sisters. The only part that was better was I didn’t have to sing, and I could look down at my hands instead of the audience.
Anyway, I tried playing the guitar again tonight before sitting down to write this letter. My hands still work. I played the picking pattern perfectly. It was just nerves before, so I’m not sure what I’m going to do about that. I think I just have bad stage fright or something, which is not cool to admit, but I hope there’s a solution.
Love,
Aaron
P.S. Happy New Year! We went to my cousins Karl and Erik’s house in Bemidji, Minnesota, which I’ll tell you more about later. They’re the ones who told me about you. Erik plays the drums, and Karl plays the violin, but he’s also really good at guitar.
Memoir in Progress
Earlier chapters:
Chapter 1: Quitting Hockey →
Chapter 2: Quitting Hockey (for Real) →
Chapter 3: The Guitar Lesson →
Chapter 4: I hated singing in church →
Chapter 5: We didn’t have a TV →
Chapter 6: You have a nice voice, Aaron →
Chapter 7: My first guitar performance is in one week →


Pingback: 3 on Thursday — 11/19/2026 – Aaron Espe